NCDRC ORDERS REFUND TO HOMEBUYER FOR DELAY OF 1 YEAR

Recently in the case of Shalabh Nigam vs Orris Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., the Apex Consumer Commission (NCDRC) , giving hope to lakhs of aggrieved homebuyers, has quantified a time period of one year for delayed projects beyond which homebuyers/investors can claim refund from builders.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court and Consumer Courts have repeatedly held that homebuyers cannot be made to wait indefinitely, but the issue relating to when refund can be claimed in case of delay was not clarified. The plea was preferred by a Delhi resident Shalabh Nigam, who booked a flat in 2012 in the luxury housing project, Greenopolis, in Gurgaon being developed by Orris Infrastructure and 3C Company.

The Buyer had made a payment of around Rs 90 lakh against the total cost of around Rs 1 crore. As per the Builder-Buyer Agreement, the flat was to be handed over within 36 months, with a grace period of six months, from the date of allotment. The Buyer approached NCDRC seeking its direction for either refund or time-bound possession of the flat when the builder failed to complete the project within the specified time.

The commission directed the builder to complete the construction and hand over the flat, complete in all respects as per the agreement, by end of September 2019 after obtaining occupancy certificate and to pay compensation at the rate of 6% per year on the total deposit for the delayed period even after handing over Possession. It further directed the builder that in case of non-delivery of flat within the deadline prescribed by commission, NCDRC, the builder will have to refund the entire amount with 10% interest.

The Court further observed -

“It is now established that allottees have the right to ask for refund if possession is inordinately delayed, particularly beyond one year,”

On the contention of the builder that the buyer had discontinued paying installments and if refund is ordered, then there will be a forfeit of 10% of the amount as earnest money, as per the agreed clause, the commission rejected the same stating that the installments were paid up to the 7^th stage and the payment was stopped later as there was no progress in the construction.

Comments

RERA Awards Rs. 65 Lakhs Compensation to Homebuyer for 9 Years Delay in Flat Possession

CA Ramesh Agrawal In a recent decision, the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA) has directed a builder to compensate a homebuyer with ₹65 lakh for an inordinate delay of over nine years in handing over a flat in Gurugram. Key Highlights: Background of the Case : The homebuyer had booked a flat in 2013, with the developer promising possession within a stipulated timeframe i.e., 7 th December 2015. However, the possession was delayed by more than nine years. Developer's Justifications : The builder attributed the delay to unforeseen circumstances, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the demise of the chairman of environmental impact assessment (EIA) committee, and inadequate water supply. H-RERA's Verdict : After reviewing the case, HRERA rejected the developer's justifications, deeming them insufficient to warrant such a prolonged delay. The authority emphasized that the reasons cited did not qualify as fo...

Municipality Demolishes Illegal & Unsafe Structures

CA Ramesh Agrawal The Sambhajinagar Municipal Corporation (CSMC) has started an anti-encroachment campaign, to keep the city clean, safer, free up public space, etc. Details of the same are mentioned as below: - Drive Moves To Gulmandi Area: - After cleaning up areas like Beed Bypass and Mukundwadi, now the clean campaign has moved to Gulmandi area, which is busy & crowded market zone. The move shows that the Authorities are serious for removing illegal building all across the city. Illegal Constructions & extension demolished: - The Authorities have targeted illegal buildings & extension of around 25 Shops in bustling Rangar Galli Market & its surrounding areas. During the operation demolition of a run-down building was carried out with the presence of police. Ongoing Efforts : - Additional Municipal Commissioner, Mr. Santosh Wahule explained that this campaign in Gulmandi was carried out on the instructions of the Civic Chief G. Sreekanth. This clean campaign ...

Mandatory Uploading of Occupancy and Completion Certificates

CA Ramesh Agrawal In a significant move to enhance transparency and protect homebuyers' interests, the Odisha Real Estate Regulatory Authority (ORERA) has mandated that developers upload occupancy and completion certificates of housing projects onto its official website. This directive aims to ensure that residential projects comply with established norms and are fit for habitation. Definition of Certificates: Completion Certificate: A legal document confirming that a building has been constructed in accordance with approved plans and complies with all applicable regulations. Occupancy Certificate: A document issued by the local authority certifying that a building is suitable for occupation, ensuring it meets all necessary safety and habitability standards. Mandatory Upload Requirement: Developers are now required to upload both completion and occupancy certificates onto the ORERA website upon proj...

RERA Master

Search This Blog